Sober Drivers Getting Falsely Arrested for DUI

Aggressive police tactics lead to increase in innocent motorists being charged with drunk driving.

There has been an increase in the numbers of sober drivers being falsely charged with driving under the influence across the United States. Despite laws that establish a blood alcohol content for intoxication at .08%, law enforcement agencies in several states, Ohio in particular, have adopted a zero tolerance position on alcohol. Both Maryland and the District of Columbia have criminal drunk driving penalties for motorists with a BAC under the legal limit. Drunk driving is a serious issue though the effort to make the streets safer has lead to many innocent drivers being caught up in a legal nightmare.

A man from Corvallis, Oregon is one such case. Brian Noakes was charged with suspicion of Oregon DUII after a traffic stop for having bloodshot eyes. He explained that he had a cold though the police officer was convinced that he was driving under the influence. While being arrested, Noakes wife asked what was happening and police threatened to Taser her. A breath test showed that Noakes had no alcohol in his system and a urine test came back negative for drugs. The district attorney declined to prosecute the case though Noakes will continue to have a permanent arrest record for drunk driving.

Washington, like several other states, does not allow arrests for traffic offenses, including driving under the influence, to be removed or expunged from a person’s record. That means that even if a defendant is found innocent or never formally charged, he or she could suffer the consequences of a false arrest for the rest of their life. Noakes’ arrest, in fact, cost him his job.

Noakes is suing the city of Corvallis and David Cox, the arresting police officer, for violation of his civil rights and false arrest. He also wants an unspecified amount of money for reimbursement of legal fees and damages. An internal police investigation found that the arrest was unlawful and the threats were improper. It was also determined that Cox had a known pattern of unjustified DUI arrests of motorists who were not legally intoxicated. Those arrests helped earn Cox praise for being one of the top DUI enforcers. He has since resigned from the force and left the state.

The pattern of false arrests for suspicion of driving while intoxicated is not limited to one state or one jurisdiction. More than 150 arrests for drunk driving in Cook County - Chicago were dismissed after a single officer was indicted for felony perjury for falsifying arrest reports. A motorist was accused of Arizona DWI because of what the officer described as slurred speech, when the defendant had actually just had denture work performed. A blood test showed a BAC of .22. Even without evidence of intoxication, the prosecutor filed three felony charges and the defendant eventually spent $12,000 in legal fees to defend herself.

Last year the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration, with input from the American Beverage Institute, updated its anti-drunk driving slogan to ‘Over the limit. Under arrest’ in effort to acknowledge that one can engage in responsible social drinking and legally drive after. Texas however clings to the old slogan ‘Drink. Drive. Go to Jail.’, leading an Austin DWI attorney to note that a percentage of his clients were not legally drunk at the time of their arrest.