Supreme Court Rules DUI Not Violent Felony

Ruling says drunk driving conviction not subject to enhanced jail term.

The United States Supreme Court ruled Wednesday that driving under the influence is not equivalent to violent felonies. That means that convictions for DUI do not warrant enhanced prison sentences during the penalty phase of criminal cases.

Whereas the justices agreed that drunk driving can result in bodily harm and death, they found the offense to be different from crimes with purposeful action, such as murder or rape.

The ruling stems from a case involving a New Mexico man with an arrest record for drunk driving. He was found guilty of possession of a gun, which was illegal because of his felony DUI conviction. The prosecutor attempted to invoke the Armed Career Criminal Act to increase the defendant’s prison term. The Act is typically applied to violent felonies or aggravated drug cases.

The justices voted 6-3 in their ruling DUI is not a violent felony, with Justices Alito, Souter and Thomas dissenting.

If you have been arrested for drunk driving, then you will need to hire a qualified DUI attorney.

Posted Thursday, April 17, 2008
Filed in DUI LawsDUI News  | Permalink |  Comments (4)
trackback URL:  http://www.dui.com/dui-library/legal/supreme-court-rules-dui-not-violent-felony/sbtrackback
del.icio.us   Digg   Yahoo   Google   Spurl
Posted by Nancy S. Dinant at 2008-12-01 14:21
I for one have to disagree with this ruling. I am a convicted multiple DUI offender (3 in all-in California). I spent 256 day in a residential substance abuse facility in stead of Chowchilla (a California state prison for women-not county jail). My sentence was 2 felonie counts and 6 years in Chowchilla. I served my time and found recovery where I was at for my alcoholism and prescription drug abuse. I know the system works if you are willing to change-one day at a time. No one, not even a judge could change me. Today I am back in school pursuing the career of a substnace abuse counselor and child psychologists. So yes you can change-even if you are an alcoholic and a multiple offender. I am living , daily proof of that.
Posted by The invisible man at 2009-01-28 09:49
Nancy, I'm confused by your decision to disagree with the ruling.Do you disagree because you think dui is a violent felony or are you saying that you disagree because you got treated as if you were a violent felon by receiving an enhanced sentence?
Posted by WHISPER at 2009-07-09 16:13
yes i agree that people can change u are blessed in a sense because i just being released from prison have come across many women whom are doing a great amount of time for DUI for one a great friend of mine whom was not past the alcohol driving limit although the saying is 1 is too many a thousand never enough any how the point is she is serving thirty five years in the florida dpt. of corrections i feel the sentence was kindve steep no i do not condone drinking and driving yes i do feel a punishment is do but a life sentence will not bring the victim back and in her defense when the accident occured she did have the right of way but in this state punishment is doled by who is alive to pay for the consequences not by actual fault whether partial or non partial...
Posted by Pat at 2009-07-09 20:43
that's statement for everyone....could happen to you and can be a happening to you. For those, who think that it couldn't happen to me...your wrong. Here's the question of the day..

Are you any different than a convicted OUI felony?
Have you had two glasses of wine at dinner and drove home?
Did you have a glass or wine or scotch with a friend after work and then head straight home for dinner with the family...oops maybe you grabbed two...

Did you drive...you were lucky that someone else didn't crash into you or maybe you hit someone who cut you off...catch is you had the drink or oopps maybe 2 at the crash site....were you drunk...
A Library of Drunk Driving Articles, DUI News and Drunk Driving Research

Topics: DUI NewsRelated DUI StroriesCelebrities DUI Charges

Legal: DUI Laws and Drunk Driving Court Decisions

Alcohol and Drugs: Dependencies, Drug Abuse and Health Issues
Topics: Health Costs Treatment Use and Abuse

BAC: Blood Alcohol Content Information

Fatalities and Accidents: Drunk Driving Accident Statistics and Stories
Topics: Statistics

Victims of Drunk Driving: Victims of Drunk Driving Articles and Information

Minors: DUI Laws and Prevention Dealing With Under Age Drinking

Prevention: Programs and Laws Attempting to Prevent Drunk Driving
Topics: MADD

Research: Alcohol History, DUI Laws and Drunk Driving Related Information

Federal DUI: DUI Laws Pertaining to Pilots and Other Federal DUI Information

Foreign: Alcohol, Drugs and Drunk Driving Worldwide

Peculiar Drunk Driving Articles: Unusual and One of a Kind Drunk Driving Articles